PRINT THERECEIPTS Open a case

Before you believe a trading claim, print the receipt.

Type in what a trading video or course promised you. Get a receipt that shows if it adds up, or if it is just luck. Like an inspection before you buy a used car.

What did they promise?

% of trades win
to 1

A "1:2 risk-reward" means 2.

trades
% of the account
trades they actually showed you
Trading costs What each trade costs: the fees, and the gap between the buying price and the selling price. Counted as a share of the money at risk.
This is their best run out of Sellers show their best account, month or strategy. Luck gets more chances that way.

The receipt changes while you type. This button takes you to it.

Exhibit A

One year, starting with $10,000

The same number of trades at the same risk, in two worlds. Each step up the dollar scale is ten times the one below. Thin lines are simulated accounts.

View as table
Exhibit B

Could luck fake this record?

shows this record by luckdoes not

What each stamp means

Every receipt ends with one stamp. Here is what each one tells you.

How believable is this claim?

This is the stamp on the receipt at the top of the page. It only does the math on the numbers you type in.

  • Realistic

    Possible.Skilled traders really hit numbers like this. Still not proof.

  • Unlikely

    Possible, but very hard.Few ever keep this up.

  • Doubtful

    Hard to believe.Ask for proof.

  • No record

    No one on record has kept this up.Be careful.

  • Loses on paper

    Loses.With these numbers, the money shrinks over time.

On a real test

This is when we test a claim on past market data. You see these stamps on the case files, and on your own receipt.

  • Not supported

    Not there.We tested it the way it was described. The promised result was not there.

  • No edge found

    Luck.It did no better than luck.

  • Unproven

    Not yet.Something showed up, but it is too weak to count on.

  • Held up

    Passed.It passed our tests. That is still not a promise about tomorrow.

While your claim waits

You see these on your receipt page, before your receipt is ready.

  • In line

    Waiting.We have your claim. It is waiting for its turn.

  • Rules needed

    Unclear.No clear rules yet, so we can't test it.

We check the claim, not the person.

Case files

Public claims, and a few of our own, run on historical market data. Each file says what was tested, with which costs and controls, and where the test falls short. Names are blacked out. The numbers are not. These fourteen come from an archive of more than 500 studies, and the first one is our own.

Five tests every claim has to pass

Before a new audit runs, its rules are written down and time-stamped. Then the claim goes through these five, in order.

  1. Real costs

    Every trade pays its costs: the real bid and ask where we have quotes, a stated cost model where we do not. In our files, most claims fail right here.

  2. The index

    Results are compared with simply holding the market over the same days.

  3. A random twin

    We take the same number of trades at random moments in the same kind of stock. The signal has to beat its twin.

  4. An unseen second half

    Rules are fixed on the first half of the data and judged on the second.

  5. A higher bar for more tries

    Test a hundred ideas and a few look brilliant by chance, so the pass mark rises with every variation tried.

Open a case

Send a claim that was posted in public. We code it as described, test it on historical market data and send back the receipt. We never tell you what to buy or sell.

A video link alone is not enough. We test rules, so we need them in words.

One image. We read the claim from it and keep it with your case.

We email you the link to your case page now, and again when your receipt is ready.

Pick one check